Skip to main content

Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher



Thirteen Reasons Why is a YA fiction novel by Jay Asher. It is a New York Times Bestseller and is now a Netflix Original Series. This review is about the BOOK ONLY. I have not watched the show. For parents interested in the show's content, IMDB.com has a detailed Parents Guide. I can say that the show is rated TV-MA for a reason.

When Clay comes home from school one day, just a few weeks after his classmate Hannah Baker committed suicide, he finds a shoe box full of cassette tapes addressed to him. When he begins to listen, he can't believe what he hears. It's the voice of Hannah, explaining why she committed suicide, and how the actions of 13 different people contributed to her decision. Clay is instructed to listen to all of the tapes and then pass them on. But why is Clay included? What did he ever do to Hannah?

Sex: Sex is a big theme in this book. The majority of the sexual discussions revolve around rumors and aren't very detailed or graphic. But there are at least two scenes that are very graphic. Also, a character is raped, and while the scene isn't very detailed, it's still very disturbing.

Language: Mild to moderate. There actually isn't a lot of language in the book, but a few of the words are pretty strong.

Drug/Alcohol Use: Several instances of underage drinking at parties. The rape is related to underage drinking.

Violence/Gore/Frightening Scenes/Death: The main theme in this book is suicide. There is also sexual harassment and abuse.

Final Note: I'm torn on what to say about this book. Some people have the opinion that it glorifies suicide and I can't say that I agree. (Again, I have no idea about the show - just the book). Because it's told in both Hannah's voice and from Clay's point of view, this novel is a true depiction of not just how someone can reach the point of suicide, but also how much suicide affects the people left behind. Jay Asher does a wonderful job getting the reader to feel empathy for both Hannah and Clay. It's also important to note that this book shows how seriously our actions, words, and choices can affect other people. We should always strive to be kind and give others the benefit of the doubt. On the other hand, the sexual content is mature. So there's pros and cons to both sides.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Lady Jane by Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton, and Jodi Meadows

My Lady Jane is a YA fiction novel by Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton, and Jodi Meadows. Written in three different perspectives by three different authors, this romantic comedy tells readers what really (maybe) happened in history with Lady Jane Grey. This book was on Publishers Weekly's list of top YA books for 2016. (And it was well-deserved!) Sex: During the Edward and Gifford chapters, the boys often comment on the figures of women. People are under the impression that Gifford is a "ladies man." Two of the characters are in an arranged marriage and the book does mention in the last chapter that they "totally consummated." There are sexual innuendos but nothing graphic. Language: Extremely mild, especially for a YA book. Drug/Alcohol Use: A few mentions of drinking. Violence/Gore/Frightening Scenes/Death: There is a war and plenty of people are threatened with losing their heads, but since this book is a comedy, it's nothing graphic or seriou...
2 comments
Read more

The Ethan I Was Before by Ali Standish

The Ethan I Was Before is a middle grade fiction novel by Ali Standish. Ethan and Kacey were the best of friends. But when a terrible accident rips them apart, Ethan and his family pick up and move from Boston to a small town in Georgia. Now Ethan must figure out what life looks like moving forward. He meets Coralee and is enthralled by her marvelous stories. Can the two of them share secrets and give each other the friendship they both long for? Sex: None. Language: None. Drug/Alcohol Use: None. Violence/Gore/Frightening Scenes/Death: There are several suspenseful scenes. Death is a big part of the story line as well. Final Note: I loved this book! This is Ali Standish's first novel and she hit it out of the park. It was hauntingly beautiful. My heart ached for Ethan. I think readers grades 6-8 would really like this one.
Post a Comment
Read more

What is The Rapid Reader?

Hello fellow parents and friends! My name is Danielle. I had the idea for this blog a couple of years ago when I was working in my son's school library. It was a known fact that I was an avid reader of middle school and young adult literature and several parents would ask me about books before checking them out for their kids. (Or buying them at the book fair!) Because I read so much, I've never worried too much about what my kids might be reading. My oldest is only eight years old and anything he's read, I've read already! But what about parents who don't necessarily enjoy reading or have the time? I wanted to offer a resource that gave these parents the chance to make educated decisions about books their kids are reading. That's how this blog was born! Before we go any further, I want to point out that I am strongly opposed to book banning. I believe in freedom of speech and expression of art through literature. But I also feel strongly that kids should ...
1 comment
Read more